Untangling the Cocoa Riddle: West Africa's Embeddedness in the Global Chocolate Chain
A Colonial Legacy of Cocoa Production
The world's insatiable appetite for chocolate hinges on a story deeply intertwined with West Africa's cocoa production. This global phenomenon finds its roots in a complex web of historical events, political manoeuvring, and economic interests. To truly grasp the cocoa problem, we must journey back in time to understand how West Africa became intimately embedded in the global chocolate chain.
Colonisation and the Cash Crop
The rise of cocoa as a dominant crop in West Africa wasn't merely a matter of geographic suitability, although the region's lush rainforests undeniably offered an ideal environment for cultivation. The critical role played by colonisation in reshaping the agricultural landscape cannot be overstated.
During European colonialism, African lands were systematically transformed from diverse, self-sustaining farming practices into mono-crop systems. These systems were designed to meet the insatiable demands of the colonial powers. With its surging popularity in Europe, Cocoa emerged as a prime candidate for this transformation.
Colonial powers ruled over African territories through entities often called companies, such as the East Africa Company or West Africa Company. These companies significantly influenced economic and agricultural policies in the colonies. Under their auspices, cocoa farming was introduced as a "cash crop." This seemingly innocuous term belied a profound shift in the purpose of agriculture in these regions.
In essence, cocoa cultivation was no longer primarily about sustaining indigenous farmers and their communities. Instead, it became a means of generating cash and resources for the colonial powers, often far away in Europe. This shift represented a fundamental change in the agricultural landscape that laid the groundwork for the complex dynamics of the cocoa industry in West Africa that persist to this day.
The Farmer-Government Disconnect: A Systemic Psychological Legacy
This profound transformation in the cocoa industry gave rise to a substantial disconnect between the cocoa farmer and the broader cocoa value chain. The reality for smallholder cocoa farmers in West Africa became increasingly limited to their interactions with the government, specifically through agencies like the Ghana Cocoa Board. This isolation from the global cocoa market had several implications, most notably the normalisation of a restricted worldview.
For generations of cocoa farmers in Ghana and other West African countries, their understanding of the cocoa industry was confined to this government-mediated relationship. It became the norm to receive a fixed price for their cocoa beans because, over time, it was systemically ingrained as the norm. The government's role as the sole buyer of cocoa beans created a controlled environment where farmers had limited exposure to market dynamics.
This systemic limitation was not just economic; it extended to the realm of knowledge and awareness. Smallholder farmers, both new and experienced, operate within a cocoon of information asymmetry. They were, in essence, shielded from the broader world of cocoa pricing and global market forces. As a result, many cocoa farmers could not fully comprehend the potential value of their produce or explore alternative avenues for selling their beans.
This controlled reality led to normalising a fixed-produce price and selling exclusively to entities like the Ghana Cocoa Board. It wasn't merely a matter of choice but a deeply embedded psychological construct. The concept of actively seeking market opportunities, negotiating prices independently, or participating in value chain decisions remained largely alien. This lack of exposure created a mindset of complacency, where farmers were content with the familiar, even if it meant settling for less than the actual value of their labour.
The systemic limitations placed upon cocoa farmers' knowledge and agency during the colonial era have had a lasting impact. This historical role, which restricted their interactions with government channels, perpetuated a sense of helplessness and dependency. It's a psychological legacy that continues to influence how cocoa farmers perceive their role and potential within the industry, even in the post-independence era.
Post-Independence Strategies
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Cocoa Diaries Newsletter to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.