Nestlé's press release announcing an innovative plan to tackle child labour risks, increase farmer income, and achieve full traceability in cocoa production has sparked interest and raised questions. This article will focus on the complexities surrounding Nestlé's conditional aid strategy and critically examines the implications and limitations of their approach to increasing farmer income within the cocoa sector. The next two articles will focus on the Child labour control and traceability claims in the plan. In the end, this critical article seeks to look at the underlining.
The Illusion of Increased Income:
Nestlé highlights the importance of increasing farmer income as a key element of their initiative. As seen in the press release,
“Our holistic approach aims to deliver long-lasting impact by incentivising the enrollment of children in school while advancing regenerative agriculture practices and gender equality. The program rewards practices that increase crop productivity and help secure additional sources of income, which aim to close the gap to living income and help protect children.”
Upon closer analysis, Nestlé's conditional aid approach to increasing the income of Smallholder Cocoa Farmers reveals inherent flaws. While the provision of financial support may initially appear beneficial, it fails to address the long-term sustainability and true empowerment of Smallholder Cocoa Farmers. Relying solely on conditional aid or handouts for income generation is an inadequate strategy.
Sustainable income growth for Smallholder Cocoa Farmers cannot be achieved through external support alone. Instead, true empowerment comes from enabling Smallholder Cocoa Farmers to become independent businesspeople with the autonomy to determine their own product prices, invest in their farms, and improve their overall livelihoods. Nestlé's approach, in contrast, focuses on providing cash incentives for Smallholder Cocoa Farmers to adopt specific agronomic practices that align with the company's standards.
It is important to recognise that Nestlé's primary goal is not to assist Smallholder Cocoa Farmers in increasing their income but rather to ensure a steady supply of cocoa beans to meet its own standards and production needs. By incentivising Smallholder Cocoa Farmers to adhere to certain practices, Nestlé maintains control over the quality and quantity of cocoa beans without granting farmers the freedom to set their own prices.
Consequently, this approach effectively disenfranchises Smallholder Cocoa Farmers from creating economic value based on their own standards and pricing mechanisms. It perpetuates a system in which Smallholder Cocoa Farmers are beholden to Nestlé's requirements, rather than being active participants in determining the economic value of their produce.
To truly empower Smallholder Cocoa Farmers and enhance their income, a more comprehensive approach is needed. This entails giving Smallholder Cocoa Farmers the agency to set their own prices and establish mutually beneficial partnerships within the cocoa value chain. By shifting the focus from conditional aid to fostering genuine economic independence, the long-term sustainability and prosperity of Smallholder Cocoa Farmers can be realised.
Addressing Root Causes for Sustainable Change:
To truly address the underlying issues faced by Smallholder Cocoa Farmers, Nestlé's approach must go beyond conditional aid and tackle the root causes of income instability. This entails recognizing the unfair pricing mechanisms and inadequate value chain governance that perpetuate the challenges faced by farmers.
By engaging with Smallholder Cocoa Farmers as genuine partners and actively involving them in decision-making processes, Nestlé can play a transformative role in promoting sustainable income generation. This means creating avenues for dialogue, fostering transparency, and supporting initiatives that enhance the economic opportunities and overall well-being of Smallholder Cocoa Farmers.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Cocoa Diaries Newsletter to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.