Mobile Money in Ghana: The High Cost of Convenience for Cocoa Farmers
the economic impact of mobile money on Ghana's rural farmers. Our in-depth analysis of transaction fees, the E-Levy, and the call for fair financial practices."
In a world quick to celebrate technological triumphs, the news of Koa Switzerland & Ghana receiving the Open API Merchant of the Year Award from MTN Ghana 2023 National Mobile Money Awards shines a spotlight on a modern marvel: mobile money. This accolade is not just a badge of honour but a mirror reflecting the double-edged sword of digital finance in the lives of those it was meant to uplift—the cocoa farmers of Ghana. As we applaud the strides in innovation, we must also scrutinise the reverberations felt at the grassroots level. This piece is an exploration, a call to gaze beyond the glitter of awards to the gritty reality on the ground.
We have already performed the quantitative analysis on the impact of mobile money being used as the medium of payment by KOA to Farmers.
Understanding Mobile Money:
Mobile money, a beacon of financial empowerment, was envisaged to bridge the divide between the banked and the unbanked, providing a lifeline to those in Ghana's remote corners. A study by the Consultative Group to Assist the Poor (CGAP) extolled its potential, underscoring how such platforms could transform financial access for the poor ("Financial Inclusion and the Role of Mobile Money in Ghana," CGAP, 2018).
However, as we juxtapose the mobile money model against traditional banking, a stark inequality emerges. Banks, with their structured fee systems, often impose a flat monthly service charge, a model that, while not perfect, tends to favour the affluent who navigate their financial landscapes with ease. In contrast, the World Bank's "Global Findex Database 2017" report reveals that mobile money, despite its initial intent, may inadvertently perpetuate financial inequity. The transactional costs, disproportionately high for smaller amounts, gnaw away at the meagre incomes of the poor. Farmers, for example, find themselves in a paradoxical bind where the very tool meant to foster economic freedom nibbles at their earnings with every transaction (World Bank, "The Global Findex Database 2017").
The irony is stark: mobile money, a system designed to democratise financial services, has, in some respects, turned into a conduit that funnels wealth from the farmers to the corporations. As these farmers send and receive money, they contribute to a lucrative loop for mobile money operators, who, according to a report by GSMA, saw a staggering $2.4 billion in global revenues from transaction fees in 2018 alone ("State of the Industry Report on Mobile Money," GSMA, 2019). This dynamic raises a pivotal question: are we witnessing the rise of a system that, under the guise of convenience, extracts precious capital from those who can least afford it?
The Reality for Farmers:
The dawn of mobile money in Ghana promised a blanket of financial security for the smallholder farmer, a shield against the unpredictability of trade winds. Yet, beneath the surface, the reality is more akin to a tax on their toil.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Cocoa Diaries Newsletter to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.